SHE CHANGED HER MIND · Ocala, Florida
ACTIVE TRIALTRIAL UNDER WAY: a jury of twelve and two alternates was seated November 16, 2026, and opening statements are set for Tuesday, November 17. Coverage follows each court day.
Dwain Hall, 54, of Ocala, is on trial in Marion County Circuit Court, charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby. She was 32, from Portsmouth, England. She flew into Gainesville on October 10, 2025, to meet Hall, a man she had known online for about two years, and she was found in a shallow grave in Marion County a week later. Hall has pleaded not guilty, and he is presumed innocent. Judge Timothy McCourt presides.
The State's own filings say Sonia came to Florida wanting to die. They also say that within about a day she messaged a friend that she was scared, that her phone had been taken and that she was locked in. Prosecutors say she changed her mind, and that Hall held her and killed her anyway. They point to the rope and the shovel he bought before she landed, her DNA on a shovel in his garage, and a knife with her blood that investigators say he mailed to Ohio. Hall told investigators he was the last person to see her alive. He has never admitted killing her.
That is the question of this trial: can the State prove that Sonia Exelby was held against her will, and that Dwain Hall killed her? No one can consent to being killed, but the burden of proving who did it, and that it was planned, is the State's alone. We are not here to convict Dwain Hall, and we are not here to acquit him. We are here to watch whether the process can prove its case fairly, and to keep Sonia's name attached to a person, not a piece of evidence.
She crossed an ocean to meet a man she knew only from the internet, and she missed her flight home. The State says she came wanting to die, then changed her mind, and that he would not let her leave. The charges, the evidence, the people and the legal questions, before the first witness. Everything here is an allegation until a jury says otherwise.
Read Full Background →Every trial day, start to finish, with the context that makes it make sense. Full uncut sessions with every recess removed, the trial told as a story, and segment analysis.
Subscribe for Daily Coverage →