He Told the Examiner Dan Was Happy
The Staged Death Trial, Days 3 to 5: the jury learned what the medical examiner was told about Daniel Akers, and what he was never told. Then Dan's phone, locked for five years, finally spoke.
Daniel Akers was 0.068 when he died. That is the number a GBI toxicologist read to the jury late Tuesday afternoon: a blood alcohol level under the legal limit for driving, with a trace of amphetamine so small the lab could not put a number on it. It is one of a hundred small facts this jury has been handed since Friday, and most of them point in two directions at once. A man who booked an eye exam for the Monday after he died. A man who typed "Dear God, I need your help. I need strength" into his phone two weeks before. A wife who texted him "that's a promise." A wife who called 911 screaming that she had tried to get the gun out of his hand.
One gunshot, one small .22 revolver, two people in a basement playroom a little after midnight on December 22, 2019. Lacy Boles says Dan put the gun to his own face and she grabbed for his arm. The State of Georgia says she shot him from the doorway and dressed the room to look like he did it himself. She is charged with malice murder, felony murder and aggravated assault, and she is presumed innocent of every one of them.
Our editorial missed Friday and Monday, so this one covers three court days: Day 3, Day 4 and Day 5. I am glad, in a way, that it worked out like that, because these three days belong together. On Friday the State built its picture of an angry wife and a hidden key. On Monday the defense took that picture apart one photograph at a time and then showed the jury what the detectives had told the medical examiner about Dan's state of mind. On Tuesday, Dan's own phone, locked for five years, was finally opened in front of the jury, and the GBI's scientists took the stand one after another.
So here is the question I came out of these three days with, and it runs under everything below. The medical examiner ruled that this was not a suicide. The jury has now learned what the detectives told him about Dan when he was making that call. He was told Dan was "extremely happy," moving up at work, buying a Christmas tree, and that he had just bought a pig. He was not told about the furlough, the declined card, the probation, the four years of prison Dan was afraid of, or a marriage that was coming apart in writing on the last night of his life. And the physical tests that might have answered the question without anybody's opinion at all, a DNA swab of the trigger, a residue test on her hands, a lab test of the holster, a swab of the sink, were never done. If the ruling rests on what he was told, what is the ruling worth?
The doctor has not testified yet. He may have a good answer. But that is the question he will have to answer, and I want you to have the whole record in front of you when he does.
Friday: her own handwriting
Day 3 opened with Detective Thomas Ogden, the first lead detective, back on the stand. The State had planned to play the whole fifty-two minute video of Lacy's third visit to the sheriff's office on January 7, 2020, most of it her sitting alone writing. Overnight the prosecutor changed his mind. Instead he had Ogden identify her handwritten statement, eight pages, and read every word of it aloud to the jury.
Before he did, the prosecutor walked him through the questions Georgia asks when the State wants a statement treated as voluntary. Was she threatened? No. Promised anything? No. Any "slightest hope of benefit or the remotest fear of injury"? No, sir. That is the legal test for a voluntary statement in this state, and it matters, because it is what lets her own words come in against her.
Her statement starts with the whole Saturday, not the shot. Dan had been acting out of character since the Monday, she wrote. He left in the afternoon with their six-year-old to get a key made and was gone nearly three hours. They texted about getting her daughter a pig. When he came back he was distant. Her father came with McDonald's that evening, and Dan was short with him, which she said he had never been. And then the night: sometime after twelve she heard the Swiffer fall, saw the back of his head going straight downstairs, followed him, and found him with the gun almost to his mouth saying something like "You can't save me, you can't help me."
Then the sentence the jury had never heard in either of her earlier accounts. She wrote that she reached out and grabbed his arm.
HOT CLIP · DAY 3 Detective Reads Lacy Boles' Statement That She Grabbed Daniel Akers' Gun Arm in Staged Death TrialI want you to notice what that sentence does for both sides. For the defense, it is the struggle, the reason her hands and his hands and the gun are all tangled together, the reason a residue test on anybody's hands would come back the way it did. For the State, it is a new detail that showed up two weeks after the night, which the State will say is what a person adds when she realizes the first version does not fit the evidence. Both readings are fair. Which one you hold depends a great deal on what else you believe about her.
CASE STORY · PT 10 · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Detective Says He Has Evidence Lacy Boles Came Downstairs With a GunThe detective who didn't record
Brian Steel's cross of Ogden had a shape this jury will recognize by now. Be kind to the man, and then show the jury what he did not do.
Ogden followed Lacy to the hospital that night to take her account. There is no recording of it. He had his phone with him, he had already used it to call the house about the consent form, and it could record like anybody's phone. Steel asked whether he could have, and should have, walked into that hospital room recording. Yes, sir. Steel called it dropping the ball, and Ogden agreed with that too. So the exact first words Lacy said about how her husband died, hours after it happened, exist only in a detective's memory.
Her clothes are gone. Ogden never asked for them and never had anyone bring her a change so the bloody ones could be kept. Was that her doing? No, he said, that was him and his team. Her hands were never tested for gunshot residue, though Ogden agreed it is common to test after any shooting. The upstairs sink, where the State says the blood looks watered down, as if someone washed, was never swabbed. Nobody knows if it is blood at all. And when Steel asked him what evidence he had that Lacy knowingly lied about washing her hands, not a mistake, a lie, Ogden said, "I don't."
Then the gun. Ogden said he and his team preserved the revolver so that it could be tested for DNA, because a working gun only fires when somebody pulls the trigger, and whose DNA was on that trigger would mean something either way. As far as he knows today, it was never tested.
Steel asked him the question at the center of the State's whole theory: did he have any evidence, not a theory, that Lacy came down those stairs into that room with a gun? The answer is short and hard to make out on the feed. The way we hear it, it is "I do," and Steel moved straight on without asking what that evidence was. That is a choice a defense lawyer makes on purpose. You never ask the question you do not know the answer to. But it leaves a hole in the record I would want filled before I decided anything, and so far nobody has filled it.
CLIP · DAY 3 Steel Demands Evidence Lacy Boles Came Down Armed and Staged Death Trial Detective Says 'I Do'On redirect the prosecutor put back what he could. A wife who fell on her husband trying to save him would have his blood on her. So would a wife who had killed him and was working over the body to arrange it. And if somebody had placed the gun before the first officer walked in, no body camera in the world would have shown it. Both points are fair. They are also both reasons the physical testing mattered so much, and it still was not done.
FULL TESTIMONY · DAYS 2 AND 3 Thomas Ogden: Full Testimony, the Lead Detective in the Lacy Boles Staged Death Trial"That's a promise"
Then came Detective Nicholas Hardy, the second lead detective, the man the defense has been talking about since its opening. He took the case over in February 2020 and now works major cases for the Acworth police. Friday afternoon he read the jury the texts between Dan and Lacy on December 21, the last full day of Dan's life, off a printout of her phone.
For a while it was the most ordinary thing this jury has heard. A grocery list. Bread, Oreos, crackers, soup. Did the Family Dollar have her hair color, and did she want the burgundy again? Then the pig, and then the money, and then the afternoon came apart on the screen.
At 3:29 Lacy wrote: "You keep treating me this way, you won't have anyone to argue with, and that's a promise." At 9:28 that night: "Run run as fast as you can. Too bad, foe, you're not the gingerbread man." And at 11:42, about an hour before Dan died, the one the prosecutor slowed down for: she was about to have his job, his paycheck and his babies, a call to his boss already arranged for the morning, "you done, son."
HOT CLIP · DAY 3 Jury Hears Lacy Boles Text Her Husband 'That's a Promise' Hours Before He Died in Staged Death TrialThose are ugly messages. I am not going to pretend otherwise, and I am not going to tell you they mean nothing. They are the State's motive, and the State will put "that's a promise" in front of this jury in closing, I would bet on it.
But read what Dan wrote back, because the jury heard that too, in the same flat detective's voice. He was not saying she did not pay her share. He was the one keeping a roof over her and the baby. Everyone else had another roof and someone else to feed them. At 10:11: "I'm trying to leave you behind. My sentence has been served." Two people tearing each other up by text on the Saturday before Christmas, both of them saying it was over. What you cannot get from those texts is which one of them walked into that basement with a gun. They describe a fight. They do not describe a shooting.
CASE STORY · PT 11 · DAY 3 Detective Reads Lacy Boles' 'I'm About to Have Your Job' Text in Staged Death Trial CLIP · DAY 3 Lacy Boles Texted She Would Have Daniel Akers' Job Paycheck and Babies in Staged Death TrialThe key on her ring
After lunch on Friday the State went to March 5, 2020, the day Hardy took a search team back to the house, seventy-four days after the death. He went because of Lacy's written statement: the camouflage gun case she said she touched with bloody hands and put back in the safe. She walked him to the safe in their bedroom closet herself. Was it locked? Locked, she told him, and she did not have a key.
The key that opened it was on her key ring. The holster was inside, along with a white press-on fingernail. Hardy cut the evidence bag open in front of the jury, and the prosecutor poked a gloved finger through the holster's belt loop. Dan was wearing sweatpants that night, Hardy said. No belt.
CLIP · DAY 3 Detective Links the Safe Key Lacy Boles Denied Having to Her Own Key Ring in Staged Death Trial CASE STORY · PT 12 · DAY 3 Detective Agrees Lacy Boles Seemed to Hide the Keys to the Safe in Staged Death Trial CLIP · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Detective Says Daniel Akers Wore Sweatpants and No Belt for the Gun HolsterThat key is the strongest single fact the State had on Friday. A woman who says she has no key, standing in front of a safe her own key opens, is a woman a jury will look at hard. Hold on to it, though, because on Monday the defense went after exactly where that key came from.
I did a commentary on the key and her shopping list, and what each really proves. A couple trading a grocery list at 2:28 in the afternoon, burgundy hair color and all, is one more ordinary fact the jury has to fit in beside the ugly ones.
COMMENTARY · DAY 3 What the Safe Key and Her Shopping List Really Prove About Lacy Boles in the Staged Death TrialThe interview, and a mistrial motion
Then the jury watched the March 5 interview, about an hour of it, with Hardy telling Lacy at the start that he does things a certain way and that reading her rights was only standard practice. She told him something none of her earlier accounts had: Dan had a drug problem, and when he used he got paranoid, convinced she was recording him for some kind of reality show. She told him the rest much as she had written it.
CASE STORY · PT 13 · DAY 3 Jury Hears a Detective Tell Lacy Boles 'I Do Things a Certain Way' in Staged Death Trial CLIP · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Interview Tape Shows Detective Telling Lacy Boles 'I Do Things a Certain Way' CLIP · DAY 3 Detective Tells Lacy Boles the Dispatcher Never Asked Her to Pick Up the Gun in Staged Death TrialTwo moments on Friday afternoon had nothing to do with the evidence and everything to do with how this trial is being run, and I want to put both on the record.
The first came right after lunch. The prosecutor's first question to Hardy was whether, while the texts were being read, he had seen the defendant laughing. Hardy said he saw her put her head down, he did not see her laugh. Had he heard her lawyer shush her? There had been some talk at the table. Nobody objected. Think about what that question is. It asks a police witness to testify about how the woman on trial was behaving in her chair while the jury was watching her, and it plants the word "laughing" in the room whether the answer is yes or no. I did a commentary on it, because I think somebody should have stood up.
COMMENTARY · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Day 3: The Prosecutor Asked If Lacy Boles Was Laughing and Nobody ObjectedThe second came near the end of the day. The prosecutor asked Hardy, in general terms, why body language matters in an interview, and Hardy said that from watching people's movements he can tell whether they are telling the truth. The jury went out and Steel moved for a mistrial. Nobody may tell a jury whether someone is lying; that judgment belongs to the jurors alone. The State had never given notice of Hardy as any kind of expert in body language. And the question came right after Hardy had been taken back to the interview of Lacy, so the jury could only hear it one way.
Judge Bucci denied it. He said he did not hear the detective comment on Lacy's body language, and if it stopped there he saw no problem. Steel renewed it and was denied again, and asked that the answer at least be struck. It was not, and the jury was not told to disregard it.
I think the judge got the mistrial right and the instruction wrong. A mistrial is the last resort, and one general answer is not the end of a fair trial. But an answer that tells a jury "I can tell when people are lying," from the detective who then spends an hour on tape across the table from the defendant, is exactly the kind of answer an instruction exists for. It costs nothing to tell the jury that credibility is theirs and no witness can decide it for them. Not giving it leaves the answer sitting there. Steel asked for a mistrial he did not want, and I explained why in a commentary.
CASE STORY · PT 14 · DAY 3 Brian Steel Moves for Mistrial Over Body Language Answer in Lacy Boles' Staged Death Trial COMMENTARY · DAY 3 Why Brian Steel Asked for a Mistrial He Didn't Want in Lacy Boles' Staged Death TrialFriday ended on one more image from the State: walking through the house on March 5, a hundred days on by his count, Hardy saw no pictures of Dan anywhere. Keep that one in mind too.
CASE STORY · PT 15 · DAY 3 Detective Saw No Pictures of Dan Akers in Lacy Boles' Home 100 Days After His Death NO BREAKS EDITION · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Day 3, No Breaks Edition: Her Texts, Mistrial Motion REFLECTION · DAYS 2 AND 3 Staged Death Trial Days 2 and 3 Reflection on What Was Never Tested and the Key on Lacy Boles' RingMonday: the picture on the wall
Steel's cross of Hardy began Monday morning, and he opened it on a frame he would use all day. Physical evidence can tell a story. People can be wrong through emotion, trauma or bias without lying. Physical evidence has no agenda. Hardy agreed to each step. Then Steel started with the last thing the State had left the jury with on Friday: the house with no pictures of Dan.
He put the State's own photograph of the entryway back on the screen, the "making memories" collage on the wall by the front door, and pointed at one picture inside it. He handed Hardy close-ups. Dan on the right, Lacy on the left. Hardy held for a while: he recognized the people, he did not see that picture that day. So Steel went to the State's own camera, photographs taken at Hardy's direction during the March 5 search, closer on the same wall. Was that the same photograph? "It does appear to me." So he had just missed it? "Yes, sir."
CASE STORY · PT 16 · DAY 4 Detective Admits He Missed a Photo of Dan Akers in Lacy Boles' Home in Staged Death Trial CLIP · DAY 4 · LIVE WED 2:15 PM ET Staged Death Trial Detective Shown His Team's Photo of Daniel Akers in Lacy Boles' Home: 'I Missed'A picture on a wall proves nothing about a gunshot, and Steel said so himself later in the day. But the State chose to end Friday on it, and the detective who said it was wrong about it, in the State's own photograph. When a fact like that gets taken back on cross, the jury is entitled to ask what else was said with that much confidence.
Then the fingernail in the safe. Nobody knows when it got there, a month before, that morning, or in the weeks after when other people could reach the safe. Nobody photographed Lacy's hands that night, and nobody wrote down what she looked like. Then the "lipstick" from the March 5 interview: never collected, a white tip in the State's own still, and on the State's own photograph from the night of the death, a tube Hardy agreed he would call a Chapstick.
The holster's first test
Here is where Monday started to matter. On Friday Hardy told the jury there was no indication of blood on the holster. On Monday Steel asked whether he remembered the crime scene lieutenant's report saying the holster had first shown a very faint reaction for blood. Hardy did not remember. After a fight over whether Steel was reading the report into the record under cover of refreshing a memory, Steel asked it the way the judge allowed. Did the first presumptive test on the holster show positive for blood? "Based on this report, yes." Hardy said the lieutenant had told him on the phone it was negative.
Why does it matter? Steel explained it himself. The reason anybody cared about blood on the holster or the safe is that if Lacy touched them with bloody hands, as she says she did, there should be blood there. One handprint on the McDonald's bag, a left hand filled in like a silhouette. Her right hand? No photograph, no video, no statement of anyone who saw it. Which hand she picked up the holster with, how she opened the safe, nobody knows.
Hold that one until Tuesday, because the lieutenant who ran that test took the stand.
What the medical examiner was told
Then Steel reached the part of this trial the defense promised in its opening. Emails between the sheriff's office and Dr. Keith Lehman, the GBI medical examiner, the detectives answering his questions about Dan. The judge would later rule most of those emails hearsay, and I will come back to that. But Hardy was asked what he himself told the doctor, and what he did not.
Did Hardy tell Dr. Lehman Dan was extremely happy? "Yes, and that email I did." That he was excited about moving up at his job? "Yes." Getting a new Christmas tree? "Yes." Did Hardy have any evidence Dan got a new Christmas tree? "I do not."
Then the list of what he did not tell him. Dan's money problems. His marriage. That he was afraid of losing his job. That he was afraid of going to prison until 2024. None of it.
And then Steel read the jury Dan's side of the December 21 texts, the side the State had moved through on Friday. 3:24 that afternoon: "We just don't have it like that. And we are not at all prepared for furlough." A card at Tractor Supply that same afternoon, declined for a $9.99 wrench. A TitleMax loan against his car. Dan writing that he was by himself, with nobody else keeping a roof over their babies. Did Hardy ever tell the doctor that? "I did not."
Then Steel asked the question all those texts were stacked up for. Hardy told the medical examiner Dan was happy. Did any of these sound happy? "You're asking for my opinion, but they sound like they're arguing."
CASE STORY · PT 17 · DAY 4 Brian Steel Asks Detective 'Do Any of These Sound Happy?' in Lacy Boles' Staged Death Trial CASE STORY · PT 18 · DAY 4 Detective Told Examiner Akers Was Happy, Not His Sad Texts CLIP · DAY 4 · LIVE THU 10:00 AM ET Detective Admits He Told the Medical Examiner Daniel Akers Was Happy in Staged Death TrialThis is the center of the case for me, so let me be careful about it.
A medical examiner deciding the manner of a gunshot death leans on two things: what the body shows, and what he is told about the person and the scene. A contact wound or a distant one, soot and stippling, the angle, the hand. And then the history: was this man depressed, in trouble, afraid? When the body leaves room for doubt, the history can tip it. That is not a criticism of doctors. It is how the job is done everywhere.
So if the history the doctor was handed said "extremely happy, moving up, buying a Christmas tree and a pig," and left out the furlough, the declined card, the probation and a marriage ending in writing that night, then the question is not whether Dan was happy or sad. Nobody can know that for sure, and the prosecutor is right that people fight with their spouses all the time without taking their own lives. The question is whether the man making the call was given a fair picture to make it with. On what the jury heard Monday, I don't think he was.
The State had an answer on redirect, and it is a real one. The prosecutor asked Hardy whether, to his knowledge, the medical examiner had full access to the entire sheriff's office file before making his final determination. "I believe so." Did Dr. Lehman ask for everything? Yes, Hardy believed. If that holds up, it matters a great deal: a doctor who had the whole file and read it made his call on more than an email. That is exactly what I want to hear from Dr. Lehman himself. What did he read, what did he lean on, and did anything he was told turn out to be wrong?
The pig, and a ruling that came too late
Now the hearsay ruling. The pig came in through Steel's questions in the morning: did Hardy know his co-worker had told Dr. Lehman a pig had actually been bought? He did. Did he ever correct it? "I did not." Steel's theory was that he was not offering the emails for their truth but for their falsity, so they were not hearsay at all. At lunch, Judge Bucci went through the emails page by page and ruled the messages between the lieutenant and the doctor hearsay for now, and kept out the lieutenant's line, as the judge described it, about who buys a pig and then buys the farm.
I don't fault the ruling on its own terms. The lieutenant who wrote those emails has not been called, and the State is right that you cannot cross-examine an email. But look at the order things happened in. The jury heard about the pig, more than once, before the ruling came down. The State asked for a curative instruction. Whether the jury is ever told to set it aside, the bell has been rung. And the man who wrote those words, the one person who could tell this jury what he told the doctor and why, is a witness neither side has called. If the State is confident in what its investigators told the medical examiner, why not put the lieutenant on the stand and let him answer for it?
"You need me to get the gun?"
Monday afternoon Steel went through the 911 call with Hardy, line by line. It is nine minutes long and very hard to listen to. What came out of it was this. At one point the dispatcher asked where the gun was now, and Lacy said it was downstairs, she hadn't touched it. Then: "You need me to get the gun? Yes?" And the dispatcher's answer, as Hardy heard it himself: "Lacy, I need you to do whatever is best for your safety."
That matters because on March 5, in the interview the jury watched, Hardy told Lacy the dispatcher never asked her to get the gun. On his own hearing of the recording, she asked whether she should, and was told to do what was best for her safety. That does not prove she touched the gun. It does mean a detective put something to her in an interview that the recording does not support.
HOT CLIP · DAY 4 Detective Hears Lacy Boles Tell 911 She Tried to Take the Gun From His Hand in Staged Death TrialSteel walked her path through the house on that call: the basement with Dan, up for her phone, the bedroom with the babies, down to unlock the front door and turn on the porch light for the responders. And then the moment her voice changes, "Dan, please, he's not breathing." Was she downstairs with him then? Hardy did not believe so, because he heard no movement on the call. But he heard no movement between the bedroom and the front door either, and she went to the front door. On March 5 his position was that she stayed upstairs and never went back down to Dan. Does he know that? "No, sir, I wasn't there."
The State came back with its own version late in the day. How many times on that call did Lacy say "help Dan," "hurry, he needs help"? "Zero." Just "help me." It is a powerful point, and on Tuesday Steel answered it by playing the first seconds again: asked what she was calling to report, she said "help me, please," and then that her husband had just done it himself. She made it clear, he said, that she was calling for her husband. Hardy agreed.
And the prosecutor tried one more thing at the end of Monday: he played the passage where Lacy answers "where's the gun now" and suggested she said "I took it down there, ma'am." Hardy heard "I took it down." Steel stood up with Hardy's own report on the call. The word "there" is not in it. Tuesday morning the prosecutor conceded it on the record: "So I added those two words." "Yes." I respect him for saying so. But a prosecutor offering a jury two words that are not in the detective's own report, on the single most disputed recording in the case, is something this jury should remember when it listens to that call again in the jury room, which the judge has told them they can.
COMMENTARY · DAY 1 Terror or Cover-Up: What the Record Says About Lacy Boles' 911 Call in the Staged Death Trial COMMENTARY · DAY 1 Why Lacy Boles' 911 Call Proves Nothing Either Way in the Staged Death TrialTwo key rings
Then Steel took on the key. On Friday Hardy had told the jury that on March 5 Lacy kept trying to put her keys into her purse, and agreed it looked like she was hiding them. His own report says she went to get her keys and put them in the purse. It does not say "constantly." "No, I did not put that in there."
And then the photographs from the night of the death. Close to the floor where Dan lay: a black clip with a blue stripe, a carabiner, a Kroger card, a car key. On the key ring from March 5, the one that held the safe key: a carabiner, a blue piece with a black clip, plugged into another lanyard. "It looks similar." Steel's point was that part of what was on Lacy's ring in March may have been lying beside Dan in December. What evidence did Hardy have that Lacy ever opened the safe with that key? "I don't." That she even knew it fit? "I don't."
The State's redirect on this was good, and I want to give it its due. The prosecutor had Hardy peel the tape off the key that was taped to the safe and match it, marks and all, to Lacy's ring. Dan's clip was a bright blue fabric; Lacy's a faded blue with a tear in it. Lacy's had an Ingles card; the Kroger card was on Dan's keys from December 22. Two different key sets, the State said, and the safe key on hers alone.
Here is where I come out. The State has shown the safe key was on her ring on March 5. It has not shown when it got there, who put it there, or whether she knew what it opened. Tuesday morning Steel asked the question that sums it up: who put the safe key on the ring in her purse found in March? "I have no idea." How many times had she ever touched it? "I have no clue." And nobody collected the keys from beside Dan's head on the night, which is why the jury is comparing photographs instead of keys.
The gun nobody swabbed
Late Monday afternoon Steel made Hardy say it plainly. The revolver is one of the most important pieces of evidence in the case, and the thing to study it for above all is whose finger was on the trigger. Lacy says Dan's. The indictment says Lacy's. The GBI crime lab has scientists for DNA. Both their DNA is known. To his knowledge, has anyone ever tested that gun for DNA? "Correct," no one has. On redirect the State said the GBI had refused, because in its view the gun had no surface DNA could normally be gathered from. On recross Steel pointed out that in Hardy's own experience DNA has been taken from the trigger of a gun before, and a revolver has a trigger, and here it was never even attempted.
NO BREAKS EDITION · DAY 4 · LIVE WED 7:00 PM ET Staged Death Trial Day 4, No Breaks Edition: Gun Never DNA TestedI want to be fair to the lab. A small revolver handled by two people in a struggle, then by medics and deputies, is not a clean DNA surface, and a mixture might have told nobody anything. But "it might not have worked" is a reason to try and report what you got. It is not a reason to never try, in a case where the whole question is whose hand was on the gun. And the jury heard on Tuesday why it can never be tried now: by the time the gun reached the firearms examiner in October 2022 and she test fired it, she was, in her words, "the last stop."
Dan's own words about prison
At the afternoon break on Monday, with the jury out, Steel argued to bring in Dan's record: a 2009 conviction, a fifteen-year sentence with probation running to 2024, and a revocation warrant filed about January 7, 2020, more than two weeks after he died. Judge Bucci read from a case the defense handed up, that a victim's state of mind is plainly relevant when the defense is that the death was a suicide, and split it. Dan's own texts about being afraid of revocation came in. The convictions and revocation papers stayed out, as bad character of the man who died.
So the jury heard Dan, a month before his death, writing to a work contact about thirty-two hours of community service he had not done: "I know if they violate me then it will violate my big probation and they will most likely lock me up until 2024." And elsewhere, that a layoff was better than jail for four years.
CASE STORY · PT 19 · DAY 4 Detective Saw Zero Texts Where Daniel Akers Said His Life Was Over in Staged Death TrialThe State's redirect was the mirror. In all the hundreds of messages, how many said "you'll be sorry when I'm dead"? "Zero." "It's time for me to end me"? No. What the messages show, the prosecutor said, is two people ending a relationship. And Steel's last exhibit of the day was a text from Dan to Lacy in September 2019, three months before, that reads like a man who could not live without her and is talking about killing. Hardy had said there were no other texts like the ones the defense showed. "I didn't remember that text."
The prosecutor moved to strike that September text after the jury left, angry about it, because the court had kept out any talk of infidelity before trial. That fight is not over. But notice where Monday left Hardy. He told the medical examiner Dan was happy. He told the jury there were no other sad texts. He told Lacy the dispatcher never asked her to get the gun. He told the jury Lacy kept hiding her keys. Each one came back on cross. None of that makes him a liar, and I am not calling him one. It makes him a detective who was surer than his file, and that is a problem for a case built on his reading of a woman's behavior.
Tuesday: the papers the jury wasn't supposed to see
Here is the strangest turn of the three days. On Monday afternoon the judge kept Dan's court records out. Tuesday morning, before our feed even came up, the lawyers worked through "some things we just had to work through," in the judge's words. Then Steel offered defense 116A, the certified Douglas County papers, and the prosecutor said: no objection.
In one sentence, the record the jury was not allowed to see Monday was in evidence. Steel read it to them a page at a time. Fifteen years in 2010 for selling drugs, five to serve. Probation revoked in 2016. Revoked again in 2018, with a felony methamphetamine possession admitted. And a third revocation warrant with Dan's name on it, signed January 7, 2020, sixteen days after he died, dismissed a month later because the defendant was deceased as of December 22, 2019.
CASE STORY · PT 20 · DAY 5 Daniel Akers' Phone Shows an Eye Exam Booked for the Day After He Died in Staged Death TrialWhatever happened before the feed came up, we did not see it, and I am not going to guess at it. But a jury is entitled to wonder, and so are we: a ruling that keeps a dead man's record out as unfair to him on Monday, and the same record in without a word on Tuesday. Either the papers were unfair to Dan and should have stayed out, or they bore on his state of mind and should have come in from the start. The judge's own words Monday, about a victim's state of mind being plainly relevant to a suicide defense, point to the second. I think they belong in front of this jury. A man on his second revocation with years of a fifteen-year sentence hanging over him, worried about a drug test, is part of the history any honest look at his last night has to include.
And then the line that told the jury the most about the investigation. Hardy had run Dan's criminal history himself. He knew about the meth arrest. These papers were sitting in the clerk's office in two counties on March 5, 2020. Had he ever seen them? "I'm seeing those documents for the first time today." Did he go and get them? "I didn't go and get those paperwork, no."
The State's answer on further redirect was fair: the third warrant was written after Dan died, and nobody can show Dan knew it was coming. That is right. But Dan's own November text shows he knew exactly what was coming if he did not finish his community service. The paper is dated after. The fear is in his own words before.
The test nobody can see
Then the retired lieutenant who ran the blood test on the holster took the stand. He started the sheriff's crime scene unit in 2000, alone out of a trailer, and ran it for twenty years. On March 5, 2020, a few months from retirement, he set up in the basement bedroom where Dan died and sprayed the safe and the holster with Bluestar, a chemical that flashes bright blue where there is blood.
The safe: no reaction at all. The holster: once, a dim whitish-green flash, gone in five or ten seconds, not the blue bloom. He waited a minute or two, sprayed again, nothing. To him that meant a false positive, something else reacting, a cleaning fluid maybe. Was there blood on the holster, in his opinion? "In my opinion, there was not."
That is a real answer to Monday's "based on this report, yes," and the State earned it. Then Steel asked one question. Was the test video recorded? Photographed? No. "So we have your word?" "Yes, sir." "Seven years ago."
He could not say whether the light in the room was on or off. Nobody told him where the blood had been on the night of the death; "no, no one bothered to do that." He never saw the safe upstairs where it was kept; it was carried down to him. His Bluestar training was a half-day introduction somewhere around Kennesaw or Marietta in the early 2000s. And the question the defense came for: did anyone ever take that holster to the GBI crime lab for a real blood test? He did not, and he did not know whether anyone did.
So the State's answer to "the holster first tested positive" is a retired man's memory, seven years old, of a flash nobody photographed, in a room whose light he cannot remember, followed by a lab test nobody ran. He may be completely right. I have no reason to doubt he is honest; he said himself he had nothing to hide and told Hardy at the time. But a presumptive test exists to tell you whether to send something to the lab. This one said maybe, and it never went.
A detective who was on the March 5 search came next and told the jury he found the safe and the key on a keychain identified as Lacy's, and watched it open. On cross, Steel's co-counsel asked the two questions the defense has asked about that key all along. How long had it been on that ring? "I wouldn't know that." Had that keychain been joined with another one at some point? "I wouldn't have known that." And wasn't it Lacy herself who walked the detectives upstairs and showed them the safe? He did not remember. "She could have."
COMMENTARY · LIVE WED 10:00 AM ET The Blood Nobody Tested and the Holster Nobody Testified About in Lacy Boles' Staged Death TrialThe phone that took five years to open
Then came the witness I think changed this trial most: the sheriff's office analyst who finally got into Dan's iPhone. When she joined the technical unit in 2021, the phone was already plugged into a machine guessing passcodes. It had been trying since about the end of 2019. Almost four years. In April 2025, under a new warrant, she tried a newer tool. It got in in about twenty minutes.
Think about what that means for everything the jury heard about March 5, 2020. When Hardy sat across from Lacy and told her Dan had passed his drug tests at work, nobody could read Dan's phone. Nobody would for five more years. Every confident thing anybody said about Dan's state of mind in 2020 was said without Dan's own phone.
And it gave something to both sides.
To the State, a life going forward. An email confirming an eye exam at the Walmart Vision Center for Monday, December 23, booked the Friday before. Searches on December 8 for "gift ideas for wife," "Christmas trees for sale near me," Christmas tree farms. The children's football registration and a wrestling association. Lights of Life, a Christmas lights attraction. And the reason the prosecutor wanted all 280 pages of search history in evidence: before trial he had her search the whole thing for the plain word for taking your own life. How many times? "Zero." Life insurance? Not found. Gunshot? No. Anything pointing to self-harm or a method? "Uh, zero."
The Christmas tree is the part I keep coming back to. On Monday the defense made Hardy admit he had no evidence Dan got a Christmas tree, after Hardy had told the medical examiner he was getting one. On Tuesday, Dan's own phone showed him looking for one two weeks before he died. So Hardy's line to the doctor had something real under it after all, though he could not have known it in 2020, because nobody could open the phone. That cuts both ways, and the jury should hold both edges.
CASE STORY · PT 21 · DAY 5 Daniel Akers' Phone Searched 'Why Is My Wife Tricking Me to Look Bad?' in Staged Death TrialTo the defense, a man under weight. "When to leave a marriage with kids." "Why is my wife tricking me to look bad." "What should I do if my wife keeps lying to me." And on December 7, at 8:03 on a Saturday morning, two weeks to the day before the last Saturday of his life: "Dear God, I need your help. I need strength." Then Steel went to the neighbors of the State's searches. Two lines below "How to handle your wife's mental health" was "crackhead Dan." Twenty-two seconds after the airport job search, "when getting badged at the airport, do you get drug tested." "California meth cities" on December 20, another meth city search on the 19th. And found live in the extraction in front of the jury: "reasons why Dan a fail." Sixteen voicemails from a title loan company, September 30 to December 5, chasing a loan against his car.
The State had answers to each, and some of them are good. "Crackhead" was probably "crackhead meme," a joke picture. There is a podcast called "Meth and the City" about what the drug does to families, though the analyst knew nothing about it. The voicemails stopped more than two weeks before his death.
11:11
Then the message. On the defense's printout, cached on Dan's phone at 11:11 and 43 seconds on Saturday night, December 21, about an hour and a half before Lacy called 911: "Tell someone you love them today because tomorrow is not promised. To my family and friends, I love you."
CASE STORY · PT 22 · DAY 5 Akers' Phone Held 'Tomorrow Is Not Promised' Hours Before He Died in Staged Death TrialOn Monday the State made much of the fact that in hundreds of Dan's texts there was no farewell. On Tuesday the jury heard something that sounds very much like one, sitting on his screen ninety minutes before the shot.
The State's redirect on it was careful and fair, and I want you to have it straight. It was in a cache folder, the phone's quick memory of things it has shown recently. Nothing showed it was saved by Dan, or sent by him to anyone. Could it have been sent to him by someone else, a meme you look at and swipe away? "It could be, yes."
So here is what the record shows and what it does not. It shows those words were on Dan's screen at 11:11 that night. It does not show he wrote them. My opinion, and it is only that: a man who is fighting with his wife by text at 10:21 and 11:16, who has written "I'm doing me" and "I'm trying to leave you behind," and who is looking at "tomorrow is not promised, I love you" at 11:11, is a man whose night was darker than "extremely happy." I can't prove that's what was in his head. Neither can anyone else, and that is the point. The State has to prove it wasn't him beyond a reasonable doubt, and this message makes that harder.
12:28, 12:42, 12:44
The timeline came out of the same phone, and it may turn out to be the most important fact of Day 5.
The State told this jury in its opening that Dan came home around 12:25, the Swiffer fell, and the shot came within seconds. Lacy's 911 call was at 12:44. On direct the analyst said, from memory, that Dan's phone picked up the McDonald's Wi-Fi network about 12:20 and joined the home network about 12:40. On cross Steel had her check her notes. The McDonald's was 12:28. The home Wi-Fi? "It could be" 12:42.
If those two times hold, Dan's phone was still at the McDonald's three minutes after the State said he was home, and it joined the house network two minutes before Lacy called 911. A phone can sit outside for a minute while a man gathers his things, and joining a network does not mean walking through the door. Steel did not overstate it, and I won't either. But the State's opening and its own witness's notes cannot both be right. Whatever happened in that basement happened fast. Two minutes is not much time to stage a scene.
The analyst also showed two mirror selfies of Dan, one with the phone appearing in his right hand that is really in his left, and the reverse in the other. The State says Dan was right-handed, and the gun was found under his left hand. On redirect the prosecutor read the backwards New York Giants tattoo to put the phone back in his right hand in one of them. The right-or-left fight is going to go on all trial. For now the jury has a man who used either hand.
The most residue the lab reports
Since Day 2 this jury has known that a gunshot residue kit was taken from Dan's hands and never heard what came of it. On Tuesday afternoon the GBI's gunshot residue scientist told them. More than five particles: the top of the GBI's scale, the point where they stop counting. That means Dan fired a gun, was close to a gun when it fired, or touched something with a lot of residue on it. The test cannot tell which.
CASE STORY · PT 23 · DAY 5 GBI Scientist Puts Akers' Hands at the Highest Gunshot Residue Level in Staged Death TrialThe prosecutor drew the honest limits out of him. A person who is shot is inside the cloud, so finding it on him is no surprise. The test cannot tell a shooter from a victim. Residue transfers by touch. And washing your hands removes most, if not all, of it. The prosecutor did not say whose hands or which sink. He did not have to. This jury has heard all week about the watered-down blood in the upstairs sink nobody swabbed.
And then Steel brought out an email from February 28, 2020, a few days before the test was run, from the scientist's manager at the lab. He did not read it aloud. He asked instead what it told him, and the scientist explained. Since 2008 the GBI does not routinely test a gunshot victim's kit, because a victim is expected to have residue and the result adds nothing. So the only reason to test Dan's kit was the chance it would come back empty. If it had, "that would have been a much better indicator that he was potentially not the shooter." It came back the other way, as high as the scale goes. And if a man fired the gun at himself, would you expect more than five particles on his hand? "Finding more than five particles of GSR is a reasonable expectation." The prosecutor asked the mirror: and for someone shot at close range by another person? "That is also reasonable to expect."
Here is what I want you to take from that exchange. The lab tested Dan's hands, by its own account, because the investigators were hoping for an answer that would hurt Lacy's story. They got the opposite. And Lacy's hands, the hands the whole State theory turns on, were never tested at all. Neither was the doorway the State says the shot came from; the scientist said a door frame can be sampled for residue. The only residue test in this case was run on Dan. The tests that might have pointed at Lacy, or cleared her, were skipped. You can believe she did it and still be troubled by that. I am.
No blood on the gun
The GBI firearms examiner told the jury the bullet from Dan's body was too damaged to say whether it came from this revolver. Nobody disputes that it did; the science just could not confirm it. The gun worked as designed. She could not tell from the bullet whether it was fired by pulling the trigger alone or by cocking the hammer first. And on a short cross from Steel's co-counsel: she test fired it on October 5, 2022, nearly three years after the death, and by then a gun is at "the last stop," every other test already done.
Then a veteran GBI crime scene agent, after a fight outside the jury about whether the State had ever given notice of him as an expert. The defense had his name and a phone number on a witness list and a three-paragraph joint report, and nothing saying he was an expert in anything. Steel argued that under Georgia's newer rules for expert testimony that matters a great deal, and the prosecutor narrowed him down to one subject. He examined the revolver in May 2020 with a magnifying glass and a bright light, looking for back spatter, the blood thrown back toward a gun when a bullet strikes. Did he find any? "No, I did not." Not on the barrel, the muzzle, the cylinder or the ejector rod. The defense asked him nothing.
That one answer is the State's physical case against a contact shot, and the State is not allowed to argue it yet. Lacy's account puts the gun at Dan's face in his own hand; the defense opened on a contact wound at the nostril. The State's theory is a shot from the doorway. Whether a contact wound to the nose should leave blood on the muzzle is a question for the medical examiner and the experts, and both sides have them lined up. For now the jury has the fact and not the meaning.
The ruling on the friend's gun plea
Tuesday night the State turned to the people who knew Dan. Before the jury came back from dinner, the judge drew the lines. The State's witnesses could say whether they saw signs of depression, describe the marriage, describe Lacy at the memorial, say whether Dan carried a gun and which hand he used. They could not say whether they were surprised, and drug use and affairs stayed out, as already ruled.
James Poag, Dan's friend since they were eleven or twelve, told the jury Dan was very caring, that he and Lacy were "not good" together, that Lacy at the memorial was "odd" and gone before it was over. He never worried about Dan's mental state. He never saw Dan carry a gun, not on his hip, not in a pocket, not in a hoodie. "Pretty sure" Dan was right-handed.
Then Steel asked one question on cross: did Poag remember pleading guilty to crimes together with Dan, and did some of those crimes involve stolen firearms? With the jury out, Steel read the certified papers. In June 2002 both men pleaded guilty, as first offenders, to criminal damage to property, for breaking a man's window and firing a gun into his home, and to receiving stolen property: two 9-millimeter and four .40-caliber handguns. The judge had the court reporter read back the questions the State had asked. Every one was about Dan carrying a gun around. A joint plea from seventeen years earlier, the judge ruled, did not contradict "I never saw him carry a gun around." Sustained, and the jury was told to disregard the question.
CASE STORY · PT 24 · DAY 5 Judge Keeps Akers' 2002 Stolen Handgun Plea From Jury in Lacy Boles' Staged Death TrialI see the judge's logic, and I still think this one went the wrong way. The State put this witness up to tell the jury, in effect, that the Dan he knew was not a gun man. That is the whole reason to ask whether he ever saw Dan with one. The witness had pleaded guilty, with Dan, to receiving six stolen handguns and to a gun fired into a house. A jury deciding whether Dan was a man who would have a revolver in his hand in that basement is entitled to know the friend vouching for him knew Dan and guns together, whatever the exact wording of the question. The ruling is in the record for appeal now, and that is where it belongs if it comes to that. But I don't think the jury got a fair picture of that witness.
Dan's niece, raised like his sister, told the jury Dan was right-handed (her father is left-handed, so she would have noticed), that Dan and Lacy were "not getting along" at Thanksgiving, that the memorial was "very bizarre." And she told a story from a family night at Lacy's house: the older daughter's boyfriend shook the raised back porch to scare them, everybody ran inside, and when she looked back, Lacy was coming down the hallway "with the gun out." Did she fire? "No." On cross the defense asked only that: everyone was scared, that was the point of the prank, and Lacy went and got a gun to protect people. "Yes."
A woman who grabs a gun when she thinks her house is under attack is a woman who knows where a gun is and is willing to pick one up. A woman who grabs a gun to protect the people in her house and does not fire is also exactly that. I don't know what that story is doing in a murder trial unless the State means to suggest something it cannot say out loud, and I'd want the judge watching it closely.
"It was Lacy's"
The last witness of the night was the niece's husband, a union sheet metal worker who worked beside Dan at Piedmont Hospital in 2019 and ate lunch with him nearly every day. He heard Lacy on the speakerphone, "screaming at him," almost weekly for three months. Dan was a second-year apprentice working toward journeyman, with a real raise ahead. Hearsay objections kept out much of what Dan had told him about his plans.
And then, at the end of Day 5, the line the State saved for last. Dan showed him this revolver in 2019, put it back in a safe, and told him it was Lacy's.
CASE STORY · PT 25 · DAY 5 Akers' Coworker Says Dan Told Him the Revolver Was Lacy Boles' in Staged Death TrialThat is the State's answer to a week of "Dan used either hand" and "nobody tested the trigger." It is also, notice, Dan's own words coming in through someone else, on the same night the judge was keeping out the friend's gun plea and the co-worker's account of Dan's plans as hearsay. Whose gun it was in 2019 tells you who owned it. It does not tell you whose finger was on the trigger in December. But it puts the revolver in her column for the first time, from a man who had no reason to care, and the defense will have to deal with it on cross.
Where three days leave the case
Lacy Boles is charged with three things. Malice murder means the State has to prove she killed Dan unlawfully and with malice: a deliberate intention to take his life, or a killing done with the kind of reckless disregard Georgia law calls an abandoned and malignant heart. Felony murder means it has to prove Dan died because she was committing a felony, here the aggravated assault. And aggravated assault means it has to prove she assaulted him with a deadly weapon, the revolver. Every one of the three rests on the same fact: that it was her hand that fired that gun, and not his. That is what the State has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, and it is the question everything above really goes to.
Here is where I come out after five days, and it is my opinion, said as a juror would think it, not a verdict. The State has proved a marriage coming apart, a wife who was furious that night and said ugly things in writing, and a safe key on her ring that she said she did not have. It has a gun with no blood thrown back on it, a friend and a niece who say Dan was right-handed, and now a co-worker who says Dan called the revolver hers. Those are real. On the question this trial is actually about, whose hand fired the shot, the State has not shown me yet that it was hers. The physical evidence that could have shown it, the trigger, her hands, the holster in a lab, the sink, the doorway, was never tested. The one hand that was tested came back as high as the scale goes. And the timeline from Dan's own phone gives the State two minutes, not twenty.
The biggest witness is still ahead. Dr. Lehman has to tell this jury what the wound shows, how close the muzzle was, and what he leaned on to rule this a homicide. If the body itself proves a shot from distance, much of what I've written above about history and opinion falls away, and I'll say so. If it leaves room, then the jury will want to know what he was told, and they now know some of what he was told was wrong.
On Wednesday the State has agreed to break its case after lunch so the defense can call an expert out of order, a man who can only testify tomorrow. So we may hear the defense's science before the State's medical examiner. That is unusual, and it could matter.
LIVE BROADCAST · DAY 3 Staged Death Trial Day 3, Full Live Broadcast LIVE BROADCAST · DAY 4 Staged Death Trial Day 4, Full Live Broadcast LIVE BROADCAST · DAY 5 Staged Death Trial Day 5, Full Live Broadcast CASE STORY TRIAL PODCAST Georgia v. Lacy Boles: Case Story Trial Podcast, Parts 1 to 25We're live in court in the morning at 8:30. Tell me in the comments what you make of the medical examiner being told Dan was happy, and the two minutes on Dan's phone, and whether you think the State can close the gap its own investigation left.
Watch the system. Question everything.
— Justice
Join the Discussion