She Wrote It on the Plane
FL v. Dwain Hall, Day 1: the State says Sonia Exelby changed her mind. What proves it?
Before the plane left the ground at Heathrow, Sonia Exelby opened her laptop and wrote a note to herself. She was trying not to have a panic attack. She was scared. From the moment the wheels left the runway she wished she was home, and she couldn't get off. Somewhere in the middle of it she asked herself the question this whole trial is going to turn on: why am I here?
Her fiancé, Stevie Hunt, found that note on the Sunday night she didn't come home. On Tuesday morning, sitting at a webcam in a police station in Portsmouth, England, he read it out loud to a jury in Ocala, Florida. It took him about three minutes. It was the first time this jury heard Sonia's own voice, and it came through the man she had told she was spending the weekend at her sister's.
Dwain Hall is on trial for first-degree murder and kidnapping in her death. He is presumed innocent of both, and nothing I write below changes that. Sonia was 32. She flew from London to Atlanta to Gainesville on October 10th, 2025, and a week later she was found in the woods in Marion Oaks, not far from his home.
Here is why this case is different from most of the murders we cover. It is at trial because Sonia may have come to Florida wanting to die. The two of them met on a website built around violence. The State's answer to that is the anchor of everything it did on Day 1: she changed her mind. And if she changed her mind, then whatever she wanted when she booked the ticket stopped mattering the moment she wanted to go home, and anything he did to her after that is a crime.
So I came out of Day 1 with two questions, and they run under everything below. The first is the one the State has to answer: what proves she changed her mind? A note written on a plane is a powerful thing, but it was written before she ever met him in person. The second is one I didn't expect to be asking this early. The lead agent told the jury that in the interview where Hall finally admitted he knew Sonia, she told him it was okay if he killed her, because Sonia wanted to be killed. She said that was a tactic. If the State's whole case is that Sonia stopped wanting this, what is anything Hall said after a line like that really worth?
The jury hasn't heard those admissions in his own words yet. They will tomorrow. I want you to have the whole first day in front of you when they do.
Two minutes of openings
Our feed joined the courtroom late, so the first thing on the record is the last minute of the prosecutor's opening statement, not her beginning. What that minute shows is a prosecutor who isn't arguing the case most people came to watch.
She walked the jury through the medical examiner: stab wounds four to seven inches deep, every one of them reaching something vital, ruled a homicide. Then the knife. It went to the state crime lab, and she asked the jurors to guess what was on it. Sonia's blood. If you followed this case before trial, that's the knife Hall is accused of mailing to a friend in Ohio. Then his phone, where she said Hall tried to erase every photograph and video of Sonia, and an examiner got them back. And on that same phone, she said, investigators found images of women being raped, tortured and killed. She told the jury what those images prove: that Hall beat, stabbed and killed Sonia for his own sadistic pleasure.
Notice what she didn't say, at least in the minute we have. She didn't dwell on a woman who came here wanting to die. The State's last word to this jury wasn't an arrangement that went wrong. It was a man who wanted to hurt her. That's a simpler case than "she changed her mind," and if the jury buys it, Sonia's reasons for getting on that plane stop mattering. I think the State knows the consent question is the hard part of its case, and the opening was built to go around it.
Then Junior Barrett stood up for the defense, and he took about a minute. He reminded the jurors that in jury selection they had already heard a set of facts both sides agree on. He told them the lawyers' words aren't evidence. And he told them that when they'd heard it all, they would conclude Dwain Hall did not murder her.
That was the whole opening. No theory of what happened in Reddick. No mention of the knife, the phone, or why Sonia came to Florida. I've watched a lot of openings and a one-minute defense opening is a choice, not an accident. A lawyer who doesn't promise the jury a story can't be held to one in closing. But listen to the word he picked. He didn't say Hall wasn't there. He didn't say Hall didn't kill her. He said Hall did not murder her. Murder is a legal conclusion. In Florida, helping someone end her own life is manslaughter, a serious crime, but it isn't murder. I'm not going to tell you that's the defense yet, because one sentence isn't a theory. But I'm going to be watching for it every day.
The man who knew her longest
The State opened its case with the man who loved her. It took eight minutes with the jury out just to get him on the screen, and then a few more for the judge to work out who could swear in a witness sitting in an English police station. In the end Stevie Hunt read England's own affirmation out loud, once for the judge and again for the jury.
He's 36 and has lived in Portsmouth all his life. He met Sonia at a cinema where they both worked. She was seventeen and he was twenty, and he told the jury he knew the first time he saw her that she was the girl he wanted to spend his life with. They were together sixteen years and lived together for about ten. She was his fiancée.
Then the prosecutor did something the side proving a murder doesn't usually do. She brought out Sonia's pain herself. Hunt told the jurors about the eating disorders diagnosed when Sonia was young, the scars on her arms and legs from cutting herself when they met, and the therapy he went to with her, on and off, for most of sixteen years. For the last six to ten years she had been too unwell to work and rarely left the house. There had been two overdoses of her prescribed medication, six to eight years before she died, both of them attempts on her own life.
And then the two years before Florida. Hunt found out Sonia had joined online forums built around violent, sadistic themes. He called England's mental-health crisis team, went to the police, and got her to a good therapist. People on those sites, he agreed, were taking advantage of her illness, and she was being sent videos of women being tortured and killed. Two or three years ago he took her passport so she couldn't leave the country. He gave it back five or six months later, when she seemed better and wanted to visit her sister in Australia. Her therapist's answer to the websites was a compromise: two phones. A bad phone she could use for those sites, and a good phone for ordinary life.
Why would the State put all of that in front of the jury in the first hour? Because the defense was going to do it anyway, and a prosecutor who tells the jury the hard facts first takes the sting out of them. I think that's smart. But it means the State has now proven, through its own first witness, the backdrop the defense needs: a woman who had wanted to die, who had been drawn to people who talked about killing, and who had tried to leave the country before.
CASE STORY · PART 1 · PUBLIC Fiancé Reads Sonia Exelby's Panicked Note From the Plane in the Dwain Hall TrialThe weekend she invented
In October 2025 Sonia told Stevie about a sisters' weekend at her sister Gemma's house, half an hour away, with her other sister flying in from Australia. He described a woman who was, for once, excited. She couldn't stop talking about her sisters and what she'd wear. She did her own hair, which he said sounds small and was hard for her. On the morning of Friday, October 10th, he got up early, walked her to the door when the taxi came, and watched from the window as it pulled away. She was wearing a flowery dress, a cardigan and a jacket, and open-toed sandals.
That taxi wasn't going to her sister's. It was going to the airport. The State mailed Hunt a binder of airport photographs weeks before trial, and in four of them he recognized Sonia going through security that morning, in exactly the dress he had watched her leave in. Those photographs were the State's first exhibit.
Later that Friday a WhatsApp message came saying she was switching phones because she had no signal. Nothing about it worried him. Sunday came and she didn't. Around seven that evening, English time, he texted Gemma to ask whether Sonia had left yet, and found out she had never been there at all. He called the police and, while he waited, opened her laptop and searched her email for anything that might tell him where she was. That's where he found the note she had emailed to herself from the plane.
He read it to the jury slowly. Part of the courtroom audio broke up while he read, so I'm going to give you the gist rather than pretend to quote lines nobody can be sure of. She was trying hard not to panic. She wished she was home and couldn't get off. She wanted to beg for help. If she hadn't been numb she could never have left the house. And near the end she wrote that even if she got away, she would be easy to find. It is not the note of a calm woman carrying out a plan.
Barrett's cross-examination was short, and I want to be fair to it, because it was good. Did Sonia have mood swings? She did, and they could last days or weeks. Was she in weekly therapy right up to the time she left? She was. Did anything in the way she told him about the weekend suggest she was making it up? Nothing. Any reason to doubt her? None. She was upbeat and normal. He had no idea she had bought a plane ticket. Barrett never said the point out loud and didn't need to: this was a woman who planned a trip across an ocean and hid it completely from the man who knew her best.
The prosecutor needed two questions on redirect to answer him. Sonia had seemed happy walking out the door that morning. And yet the note she wrote a couple of hours later didn't read like a woman in a good state of mind, did it? No, Hunt said. She was "crying out."
Those two pictures of Sonia are the whole case in miniature. The defense's Sonia planned this carefully and told no one. The State's Sonia was terrified before she ever landed. Here's what I keep coming back to: they can both be true. A woman can plan something for months and be terrified when it's real. The question for this jury isn't which Sonia is the real one. It's what happened after she landed, and whether anyone let her leave.
Her sister, and "trying to gather evidence"
Gemma Isaj came into the courtroom in person, and she gave the jury the childhood. Six children. A mother with serious mental-health problems and a father struggling with addiction. Just before Sonia's second birthday the state took all six into care and split them across foster homes. Sonia and her sister Sara were adopted together, Sonia at five, and the new family cut off contact. For thirteen years the other siblings talked about the two girls at every gathering. They were reunited when Sonia turned eighteen, and Gemma said it was as if they had never been apart.
Then she told the jury about November 2023, a family gathering before Sara moved back to Australia. Sonia asked to talk, and the two of them went into another room. Gemma had to stop at this point, and the judge gave her a moment. Sonia told her she had got into something and was terrified. People had been making horrible threats against her and against the family, saying they knew where she was and could find her. And she gave Gemma her own reason for being involved at all: she said she was trying to gather evidence, because she couldn't bear that people were being hurt and wanted to stop it happening to anyone else.
Gemma called the police and the crisis team that same day. On cross she explained it was the non-emergency line, that no officer ever came back to her, and that Sonia had shown her screenshots of threats from several men, none of them in the UK as far as she understood. One of them Sonia talked to more than the others. Gemma couldn't remember which username was which.
I want to sit on this for a second, because I don't think anyone in that courtroom did. Two years before she died, Sonia Exelby told her sister that men online were threatening her and her family, and the police in England were told. Nothing in the record yet says anyone followed up. That isn't Dwain Hall's fault, and it isn't a defense to anything. But it's part of how a vulnerable woman ended up on a plane to Florida, and the jury heard it in one sentence and moved on.
Then the weekend, from Gemma's side, and it matched Stevie's. Sonia said she'd come Friday, then that she'd meet them at the airport Saturday, then that she'd see them Sunday at two o'clock, and she was very specific about the time. Two o'clock came and went. Over the weekend Sonia sent a message saying her phone was broken and she could only talk through Messenger. The last time Gemma actually heard her sister's voice was a couple of weeks before. Everything after that was messages. That detail is going to matter: the jury doesn't know yet who was typing.
Follow the money
Detective Sergeant Darren Thomas of Hampshire police supervises one of the county's missing-persons teams, and he took Sonia's case the Monday morning after she was reported. He told the jury what his team did first: they worked the airline, her bank accounts and her phones at the same time. The airline's answer changed everything. Sonia had flown from Heathrow to Atlanta, then on to Gainesville, Florida, on October 10th, with a return booked for October 13th. She never checked in for it.
Then her bank. On Saturday, October 11th, the day after she landed, there were four attempted payments from her account to a roadside assistance business in Florida, each smaller than the last, and none went through. Her second account, at another bank, showed the one that did: £905.11, about twelve hundred dollars, to the same business. A Google search told Thomas whose business it was. It recovered broken-down vehicles and it was owned and run by Dwain Hall. It was the first time his name was spoken by a witness.
And then a fact that cuts the other way, and the State put it in itself. Almost three weeks before she flew, on September 22nd, Sonia's own card paid Airbnb £218.95. The booking was a small rental on Northwest 122nd Terrace in Reddick, for two nights starting October 10th. Barrett's whole cross was one point: the flights and the rental were both booked on Sonia's own account with her own card, and Thomas found nothing to suggest anyone else made those bookings. The rental where the State says she was held was, on this record, a place she booked and paid for herself.
CASE STORY · PART 2 · PUBLIC Agent Testifies Sonia Exelby's $1,200 Payment to Dwain Hall's Business Went ThroughThat Monday morning, October 13th, two Marion County deputies went to that rental for a welfare check. They walked the property, looked in the windows and knocked. Nobody answered. The State played a short clip of the body camera: two deputies walking up to a small, silent cottage.
"Yes and no"
FDLE Special Agent Calvin Lee picked up the trail on the American side. The payment processor's records named the owner of the roadside business: Dwain Hall, with a Gmail address built around the words "dark wolf." They showed every attempt on October 11th from two British cards, the declines, and the one charge that went through: $1,200, at 1:10 in the afternoon.
At 11:03 that Monday morning, before Lee had any of those records, he called the business number. All he knew was that Hall's business had tried four times to run a missing woman's card. The call was recorded and the jury heard it. A woman named Sonia Exelby, Lee said, had called his business a few days earlier and her payment had declined. Did that ring a bell? "Yes and no," Hall said.
Then Lee told him something that isn't in evidence anywhere: that Sonia had landed at Gainesville and set off south in a rental car. Hall took it from there. She broke down, he said, needed a tire changed and a ride the rest of the way. She had to pay first, the payment declined, and so they never went out. Where was she going? She was "very, very secretive" about everything, he said. Where did she break down? Somewhere around Reddick, out of his service area.
CLIP · DAY 1 · PUBLIC Jury Hears Dwain Hall Tell an Agent Sonia Exelby's Card Declined So He Never Went OutEverything the jury had heard that morning stood against that call. Sonia had booked a rental in Reddick herself three weeks earlier. And by the time Hall told Lee her card declined and he never went out, $1,200 of her money had already gone through to his business.
But I want to flag the rental car, because nobody in the courtroom did. Nothing in evidence shows Sonia ever had a rental car. In the next day's interview Lee himself told Hall the rental companies had no record of her. As far as the record shows, the car was an investigator's working assumption, handed to Hall on the phone, and Hall built his story around it. That's not a scandal. Agents work with what they think they know. But tomorrow the jury is going to hear Hall agree to things an agent put to him, and this was the first time it happened. It's worth noticing who brought the detail into the room.
The next day, October 14th, Hall came into the FDLE field office voluntarily, and that interview was recorded too. His story grew. Now she had sounded absolutely panicked. Now she had offered him about seven hundred dollars, a week's pay for a tire change, and he had tried to refuse. Now the card had declined at lower and lower amounts, which is close to what the bank records show. Now it was Saturday night, off exit 368, after dark, when he'd already taken muscle relaxers after a car accident. His phone, he said, had been acting strange since the weekend. Calls from Friday, Saturday and Sunday were missing from his log, and the payment app wouldn't load in the building. A declined card leaves no record, he told the agent: "It's like it never happened."
And then, without being asked, he gave his read of the woman on the phone. She seemed desperate. She swore too hard that the money was there. And it was too quiet: no engine, no crickets, no trucks going by. His impression was that she wasn't alone. Something was wrong, he said, and he stayed away. If the money had gone through, he would have gone, and he would have gone armed.
Lee walked him out and noticed what he was driving: a black Jeep Cherokee with "emergency roadside" across the back window.
Rope, paracord and a shovel
After lunch the State took the jury inside the rental. Maria Andreoli, an FDLE crime scene supervisor, processed it on October 15th and 16th. Under the porch was a garbage can, and in the white trash bag inside it she found food containers, wipes, toiletries, and two Walmart receipts. The first was timed 5:47 in the evening on October 10th, the day Sonia landed: paracord, an aerosol spray and utility rope. The second, seven minutes later at 5:54, was for a shovel, $20.39 with tax. In the same trash were the empty wrappers from a fifty-foot pack of paracord and a twisted utility line.
The rope and the cord themselves were nowhere in the rental.
CASE STORY · PART 3 · PUBLIC Crime Scene Analyst Finds Rope and Shovel Receipts in the Trash at Sonia Exelby's AirbnbAn FDLE agent explained the rental's internet router, and why it mattered. When a phone joins a home network, the router keeps a record. The last device logged before the agent's own laptop was named "Sonya-S22," and Sonia's Google records showed she had a Samsung S22. It was connected from October 10th to October 12th. It never connected again.
Then the Walmart. A loss-prevention investigator at the store on Northwest 23rd Street in Gainesville found the video from October 10th, and Agent Lee came back to the stand to tell the jury who was on it. Dwain Hall. He came in, walked the aisles, and paid at the sporting-goods register at 5:47: deodorant, two kinds of rope, gun cleaner. Then he turned into the fenced garden area, came out with a shovel, and paid for it at 5:54. The jury watched about six minutes of it in silence.
CLIP · DAY 1 · PUBLIC Agent Testifies Walmart Video Shows Dwain Hall Buying Rope and a Shovel in Sonia Exelby TrialThis is where the case changed shape for me. On the evening of the day Sonia landed, the man who told an agent he'd never gone out to help her bought rope and a shovel, and the receipts ended up in the trash of the rental she booked. Whatever Sonia wanted when she got on that plane, the State's argument is going to be that a shovel bought hours after she arrived is a plan. A plan is premeditation. And here's the part that matters for the defense's backdrop: even if Sonia had wanted to die, a killing planned that way is still a killing. Her wishes don't make a shovel innocent.
The defense asked no questions of the Walmart witness and none of Lee about the video.
The food in the trash told the rest of the timeline. A truck stop manager on Highway 318 in Reddick, right off I-75, recognized the containers: a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a tub of cut strawberries, packed exactly the way his store sells them. He found the sale, and another FDLE agent found the video. It was stamped Saturday, October 11th, at 12:06 in the afternoon. The man at the counter was Dwain Hall. That's about an hour before Sonia's $1,200 went through to his business.
CASE STORY · PART 4 · PUBLIC Agent Traces Sonia Exelby's Airbnb Trash to Dwain Hall on Truck Stop VideoPut those pieces next to each other and you have the State's Friday and Saturday. Rope and a shovel on Friday evening. Food from a truck stop seven miles from the rental on Saturday at noon. Her money to his business on Saturday afternoon. Her phone on the rental's Wi-Fi through Sunday. And the man who bought all of it telling an agent on Monday he never went out.
Then Deputy Riley Ardner came back to the stand for the morning everything closed in. At 7:50 on Friday, October 17th, he pulled over Hall's black Jeep on I-75. Hall's wife was in the passenger seat, on her way to a doctor's appointment, and another patrol car drove her there. Hall handed over a folding pocketknife and agreed to go to the sheriff's office for an interview. And for the first time all day, a juror asked a question: was this a routine traffic stop, or were they looking for that vehicle? They were looking for that vehicle, Ardner said.
That's a juror paying attention. This jury is already trying to put the timeline together for themselves, and that's exactly what they should be doing.
The lead agent, and the line she used
Late in the afternoon the State called the woman who ran the investigation. Rebekah McKinzie has been an FDLE special agent for two years, after about twenty-one with the Gainesville Police Department. She became the lead on the search for Sonia on October 13th, and she told the jury why it narrowed to Hall within days: the receipts for the rope and shovel, his conversations with Agent Lee, and a license-plate reader at the Gainesville airport that recorded his vehicle around the time Sonia's plane landed.
On October 15th, still hoping Sonia was alive, FDLE asked the FBI to track Hall's phone on an emergency basis, without a warrant. The results came back the next day. His phone had spent about an hour and a half on Sunday, October 12th, in a wooded area in Marion Oaks, near his home. That's the same day "Sonya-S22" last touched the rental's Wi-Fi. A search that evening found nothing. A grid search with a cadaver dog was planned for Friday morning.
That Friday, while the others searched the woods, McKinzie sat down with Hall at the sheriff's office. She read him his rights, she said, and didn't force, threaten or promise him anything. Her approach was non-confrontational and nonchalant, to get him comfortable, because if he kept talking she thought she could find out what happened to Sonia.
And then the prosecutor asked her the question I've been thinking about all night. In the interview, the prosecutor said, you made statements indicating to the defendant that it was okay if he killed Sonia because she wanted to be killed. Was that true? No, McKinzie said. It was a tactic, to make him comfortable telling her what he had done.
CASE STORY · PART 5 · PUBLIC Lead Agent Testifies Dwain Hall Put Himself Where Sonia Exelby's Body Was FoundLet me be careful here, because this is exactly the kind of thing we exist to look at, and it's also exactly the kind of thing that gets overstated. Police are allowed to lie to a suspect in an interview. Courts have said so for a long time, and a lie on its own doesn't make what the suspect says afterward inadmissible. What courts look hard at is a promise of leniency, or a statement that misleads someone about the law. And telling a man that killing a woman who wanted to die is "okay" comes close to that line. It isn't okay. In Florida, helping someone end her own life is manslaughter, and killing a woman who didn't want to die anymore is murder. The recording is coming in, so if the defense challenged it before trial, the judge let it in.
Here's my problem with it, and it isn't about the law. It's about what the jury is supposed to do with what comes next. The State's case is that Sonia changed her mind. The lead agent's tactic was to tell Hall that Sonia hadn't, that she wanted this. So when the jury hears Hall tomorrow say something that sounds like "she wanted it," they're going to have to decide whether that's his account of what happened in Reddick or whether he was handing the agent's own words back to her. The State brought this out on direct so the defense couldn't spring it on the jury later. That's good lawyering. But it doesn't answer the question. It just means the jury heard it first from her.
And I'll say the other side of it too, because it's real. On October 17th Sonia was still missing. An agent sitting across from the last man known to have seen her, trying anything to find out where she was, is doing her job. I don't fault her for the tactic. I'm asking what it does to the evidence.
Four hours of Harold
McKinzie then told the jury what the interview produced. For about four hours, Hall told her a story about a man named Harold. Harold had hired him to work on high-end cars at a secret location near Reddick. He'd signed a non-disclosure agreement. Harold paid him the twelve hundred dollars. There was a break, someone brought him food, and after it Hall told her he wanted to take back everything he had said for the last four hours. Then he admitted he knew Sonia Exelby, and had been talking with her for a couple of years.
CLIP · DAY 1 · PUBLIC Agent Testifies Dwain Hall Recanted His Four-Hour Story and Admitted He Knew Sonia Exelby for YearsCount the versions of that $1,200 the jury has now heard. A stranger's card that declined, so he never went out. A desperate woman who offered him seven hundred dollars and swore the money was there. Harold, paying him for two weeks of car work. And then, after a meal, Sonia. Lying to the police is evidence a jury may weigh as a guilty mind. What it means is still the jury's question. A man can lie because he killed someone, and a man can lie because he's terrified of being tied to an arrangement he knows looks like murder. The State will say the first. I expect the defense to say the second.
Where did they talk? On an encrypted messaging app called Session, whose messages can't be recovered without the phone, and on an extreme pornography website that has since been shut down. Hall told her his username there was "Alpha Sadist." He also had one called "Silverwolf44646," with the same numbers as the "darkwolf" email he gave Agent Lee. The site's records came back with both accounts deleted: Silverwolf in October 2024 and Alpha Sadist in July 2025, about three months before Sonia flew. McKinzie read the jury both profiles. In them, the user called himself a sadist and wrote about wanting a woman for "complete control." I'm not going to repeat the rest.
Sonia's account was never deleted, so a little of it survived. Her username was "Already Yours." She joined in September 2024 and last logged in on October 4th, 2025, six days before she flew. Three short messages from her to "Alpha Sadist" survived. His side of the conversation was deleted with his account, and nobody knows what he wrote back.
Then the prosecutor took McKinzie back to the interview room and to what Hall admitted once Harold was gone. He admitted staying with Sonia at the Airbnb in Reddick. He admitted having sex with her at least twice, which he called "vanilla" for him, but rough, with light choking. He admitted hitting her during sex. He admitted filming her for a few minutes on his phone and deleting the video right away, because she wasn't behaving the way he wanted. He said he was the last person to see her alive. He said he had thrown some of her belongings in a donation bin, where agents later found them. He put himself at the place where her body was found. And when they questioned him, McKinzie said, he remarked that "if you take somebody's life, that's murder."
Did he ever admit killing her? Not in so many words, McKinzie said. Did he say, or suggest, that he had helped Sonia get what she wanted? Yes, she said. He did.
That Friday, while Hall sat in that room, the searchers found Sonia in the woods in Marion Oaks, near his home. She was in her bra and her sandals, McKinzie said, with her dress laid over her. The flowery dress Stevie watched her leave in.
Thirty-three exhibits, not one objection
Barrett's cross of the lead agent was short and pointed. Before the interview, was Hall a suspect? Yes. A strong one? Yes. Did she tell him? No. He never actually said he killed Sonia, did he? He said things indicating he was responsible, she answered. He just never said he killed her. Everything she talked to him about is on that video? Yes. And both of Hall's accounts on the site were closed before Sonia was reported missing, before she ever left England? Yes.
That last point is the defense's frame for tomorrow, and it's a fair one. A strong suspect who isn't told he's a suspect, sitting with an agent whose plan is to make him comfortable, who is told it's okay because she wanted it. Whatever he says on that tape, the defense will argue, came out of a story the agent supplied. The jury should judge his words, Barrett was telling them, not her summary of them.
Now here's what I can't let go of. By the end of the day the State had put thirty-three exhibits in front of this jury, and every single one came in without an objection. The defense didn't challenge the emergency phone tracking done without a warrant. It didn't object when the lead agent described the website. And that description went well past Hall. McKinzie told the jury about the worst of what that site hosted, children included, and nothing in this case involves a child. That's evidence about a website, not about Dwain Hall, and it's the most damaging sentence the jury heard all day about something he isn't charged with.
Maybe all of that was fought before trial and the defense has standing objections we can't see. If so, it's preserved and the jury simply never saw the fight. But if it wasn't, a description like that going by without a word is the kind of thing that ends up in an appeal, and I want it on the record that we noticed it on Day 1. Whatever this jury decides, it only counts as a fair trial if they decided it on the evidence about him.
His own words, and a guest house that sounds like Reddick
The last stretch of the day was the State playing the October 17th interview itself, State's Exhibit 32, about an hour and sixteen minutes of what will be more than four hours. The laptop wasn't connected to the defense table, so the judge moved his own microphone to the television so the courtroom could hear.
The Hall on that tape is prickly and in charge of the room. He wants to talk about his wife first, who was on her way to a hospital appointment after a transplant when they pulled him over, with her medicine in the Jeep. Direct questions get direct answers, he tells them. McKinzie keeps it easy, exactly as she told the jury she would. She reads him his rights and thanks him for coming in voluntarily.
He gives her what he calls the cliff notes, the same story Lee heard three days earlier, and then he adds a theory. Someone could have been forcing this woman, he suggests, running her card for big amounts. In hindsight she was under duress, he says. She didn't seem to be talking to him but to somebody else. It was far too quiet for a breakdown. He grew up tracking in the woods, he says, and he knows what the woods should sound like.
CASE STORY · PART 6 · PUBLIC Jury Hears Dwain Hall Tell Investigators He Picked Up a Woman at Gainesville AirportThen Harold. A non-disclosure agreement for a high-profile client with cars belonging to people "like Travolta." A hidden barn of show cars and a 1933 rat rod. Twelve hundred and five dollars for about thirty-six hours of work. Asked to describe Harold, he offers a tall man whose smile was too big for his teeth, with, in his words, a "creepy serial killer vibe." Harold put him up in a guest house that weekend, he says, and McKinzie, who has the crime scene photographs of Sonia's rental, keeps asking him to describe it. A small covered porch. A table on it. Sliding glass doors. A living room and kitchen, a short hallway, a bedroom and a bathroom. On the tape, Harold's guest house sounds a great deal like the manufactured home in Reddick.
And in the middle of explaining how the weekend began, he lets slip a piece that fits the evidence exactly. Before the barn, Harold had sent him out to the Gainesville airport to pick up a client.
In the last minutes the jury saw, McKinzie asked whether anyone else had been staying with him, and Hall said it was just him. Then she came back to something he had mentioned: on Saturday night, his third trip out to Harold's, there had been a disturbance. There wasn't much to tell, Hall said. Just some screaming and yelling, and it had seemed suspicious, like the call that was way too quiet.
Think about that for a moment. Over five days and three interviews, Hall kept putting someone else in the room with Sonia. A person forcing her to make the call. A woman who wasn't alone. Screaming and yelling at Harold's. Every one of those strangers lands right where the evidence puts him.
At about a quarter to five, the judge stopped the recording for the day. He warned the jurors, more firmly than usual because a camera has been in the courtroom all along, to stay off social media, news sites, and even YouTube tonight. If you're a juror on this case and you're reading this, close the page. The rest of you, keep reading.
Where Day 1 leaves the case
Let me tell you where I think the State stands, element by element, because that's the job. The jury hasn't been asked anything yet, and only the jury decides.
Sonia is dead. That hasn't been contested and won't be.
Did Dwain Hall cause her death by a criminal act? Nobody has said so directly yet, but the circumstantial case built in one day is heavy. He was at the airport when she landed, by a plate reader and by his own slip about picking up a client. He bought rope and a shovel that evening. He bought food Saturday at noon. Her money went to his business that afternoon. His phone spent ninety minutes in the woods near his home on the Sunday her phone dropped off the Wi-Fi. He told four different stories before he admitted he knew her, and then, through the agent, he admitted staying with her, hitting her, filming her, getting rid of her things, being the last to see her alive, and putting himself where she was found. Still to come: the knife and its trip to Ohio, the DNA, the phone examiner and the recovered video, and the medical examiner.
Premeditation? The shovel is the State's centerpiece, bought within hours of her arrival. The site profiles are its motive. The defense's backdrop, that this was something Sonia joined, doesn't defeat a planned killing even if the jury believes it.
And the kidnapping, which is where "she changed her mind" lives. That is still the open question. For the State: the note from the plane, the return ticket she never used, rope bought and unwrapped and missing, the violence he admitted, a video deleted because she wasn't behaving the way he wanted. Against it: a trip she planned in secret for weeks, a rental she booked and paid for herself, a profile called "Already Yours," two years of talking to him, and a phone on the Wi-Fi for three days. Before trial, prosecutors said Sonia messaged a friend from inside that rental that she was scared and that he had taken her phone and locked her in. If those messages come in, they could close this question. The jury hasn't seen them yet.
Here's my read after one day, and it's my opinion, not the jury's. The State has put Dwain Hall with Sonia Exelby from the moment she landed to the day she disappeared, and it has shown a man who lied about all of it until he couldn't. I don't think there's much doubt left about where he was. The doubt this trial is really about is what she wanted at the end, and that's the one place the State's own lead agent told Hall the opposite of its theory. Tomorrow we find out what he said back.
NO BREAKS · DAY 1 · MEMBERS NOW · PUBLIC WED 7:00 PM ET She Changed Her Mind? Sonia Exelby Trial Day 1, No Breaks Edition: Openings to Hall's Interview LIVE BROADCAST · DAY 1 · PUBLIC Day 1 live, the full day with our live coverage CASE STORY TRIAL PODCAST · EVERY PART FL v. Dwain Hall: Case Story Trial PodcastCourt is back Wednesday morning. The judge has two short hearings at 8:00 and hopes to have the jury back in by 8:30, and the State picks up the October 17th recording where it stopped. That's the part where Harold goes away and Hall starts talking about Sonia. Then the lead agent comes back for the rest of her cross and the jury's own questions. We'll be live. Tell me in the comments what you make of the note from the plane, the shovel, and the line the agent used, and whether you think what Hall says next will tell us what really happened in Reddick.
Watch the system. Question everything.
— Justice
Join the Discussion